Treatment of Minorities in the Media – Visualizing the Other

• • 
  • Presentation speakers
    • Emmanuelle Bruneel, CELSA Paris-Sorbonne, France
  • Download presentation
    • Emmanuelle Bruneel Treatment of Minorities in the Media - Visualizing-the-Other.pdf

  Abstract:

  This contribution aims to discuss the political uses of the ‘diversity’s rhetoric’ in the French communication and media context. I will try to point out what kind of visual representation of ‘minorities’ is given that way, questioning which idea of alterity is conveyed in that specific visual discourse? In France, the minorities’ struggle for visibility (Voirol Olivier) takes place in the media and communication scope because it is the most important providing source of visibility and a political hegemonic (Gramsci Antonio) support. Visibility and visuality (Mirzoeff Nicholas) are highly at stake in the minorities’ representation issue. I will investigate the way the ‘diversity’ discourse (Sénac Réjane, 2012) is textually formulated and visually designed and what it stands for in the French media and political sphere. Indeed, many publicized documents focus on ‘promoting diversity’ to say that nobody is discriminated and that the collective identity is plural. They are part of communication strategies and deliver a positive discourse about how enlightening it is to collect many different people with various identities. It argues that ‘diversity’ is accomplished whenever all the components of the population are represented or ‘made more visible’. The accompanying pictures represent groups (within which there are a lot of coloured people or just colours) in a very enchanting way. Plus, the social injunction : “visible minorities have to be made more visible”, sounds as a paradox. That double bind allows visual representation to underline the most visible aspect : multicolour becomes a significant for ‘multiracial society’, in a way that is euphemistic and depoliticized. Then, the visual representation of ‘diversity’ strengthens a colourful idea of ‘diversity’, dealing with an emphatic representation of ‘race’. It also seems to be very mediagenic (Marion Philippe, 1997) and can be considered as a communication tool to avoid the contentious political question of social injustice and hegemonic domination. So, questioning that visual material (WJT Mitchell) intending to represent ‘diversity’ is leading us to re-investigate the tension between the French republican model and the multicultural society designed by globalisation dynamics. We will argue that ‘diversity’ is a depoliticized visual concept in the French context.

 

Related Presentations

 

Telling The Story of A Politicized National History: The Field and Habitus Making of Israeli Historians

• Alon Helled

British Born Female Caribbean Registered Nurses: Post-Colonialism and the Other

• Beverley Brathwaite

Equal in the Eyes of Capitalist God: Gay Marriage and the Contemporary Intimacy Regime

• Omri Herzog

Political Subjectivization between Identification and Dis-identification – Understanding New Social Movements with Jacques Rancière

• Dietmar Wetzel

"Not Man Enough": Masculinities and Political Conservatism in the United States

• Lauren Haumesser

Identity Struggle in Post-Socialist City - Rebranding Belgrade, Reinventing Skopje

• Nebojša Čamprag
• Biljana Stefanovska